If it wasn’t for bad luck
I wouldn’t have no luck at all
Sometimes I feel like “Born Under a Bad Sign” was written about yours truly. But I have to admit that Alice Roth was a lot unluckier than me.
On August 17, 1957, the Philadelphia Phillies were hosting the New York Giants at Connie Mack Stadium. There were 7929 fans in attendance, including Alice Roth – who was the wife of the sports editor of the Philadelphia Bulletin – and her two grandsons.
Richie Ashburn, who played center field and led off for the Phillies that day, was known for his ability to spoil good pitches by fouling them off. One of the balls he fouled off in that 1957 Phillies-Giants contest hit poor Alice Roth in the face, breaking her nose.
![]() |
A 1959 Topps Richie Ashburn card |
The game was halted briefly while the unlucky fan was administered first aid and put on a stretcher.
Ashburn fouled off the next pitch as well, and that foul ball struck the hapless Mrs. Roth as she was being carried out the stadium, breaking a bone in her leg.
(Cue the lines from "Bad Luck Blues" quoted above.)
* * * * *
Ashburn visited Alice Roth in the hospital several times before she was discharged. Her grandsons, who had to leave the game when she was injured, were given free tickets to another Phillies game later that season. (They watched batting practice from the Phillies dugout that day, and the whole team autographed baseballs for them.)
Ashburn sent Roth birthday and Christmas cards every year for the rest of her life.
* * * * *
The Phillies made it to the World Series in Ashburn’s third season with the team, but were also-rans during the remainder of his tenure in Philadelphia. (The team finished a respectable 5th the year when Ashburn broke Alice Roth’s nose, but fell to last place the following year and stayed there for four consecutive seasons.)
Ashburn was voted into the Baseball Hall of Fame two years before he died in 1997. He wasn’t a power hitter – he had only 29 home runs in his 15-year career – but he excelled at getting on base.
Ashburn’s career on-base percentage was an outstanding .396 – better than the career marks of his contemporaries Hank Aaron, Willie Mays, Roberto Clemente, and Duke Snider. He led the National League in hits three times and in walks four times.
And he was an outstanding outfielder, leading the senior circuit in putouts nine years in a row.
* * * * *
The first song to include the lyrics that are quoted at the beginning of this post was “Bad Luck Blues,” which was originally recorded in 1947 by New Orleans blues and jazz singer Cousin Joe.
Those lines also appear in “Born Under a Bad Sign,” a William Bell-Booker T. Jones song that was originally recorded by Albert King in 1967 and then covered by Cream the next year.
Click here to listen to Cousin Joe’s recording of “Bad Luck Blues.”