Mississippi in the middle of a dry spell
Jimmie Rodgers on the Victrola up high
I recently learned that Sandra Day O’Connor – who became the first female member of the Supreme Court in 1981 – was confirmed by a 99-0 vote.
Can you imagine a Supreme Court justice being unanimously confirmed today?
![]() |
| Sandra Day O’Connor |
The two newest Supreme Court justices were confirmed by much narrower margins. Ketanji Brown Jackson, who was nominated by Joe Biden in 2022, was confirmed by a 53-47 vote. Every Democratic senator voted in favor of confirming her, while almost every GOP senator went the other way. (Three Republicans did cross party lines to vote for her.)
The vote on Amy Coney Barrett, who was nominated by Donald Trump in 2020, was even closer. She was confirmed by a 52-48 vote – every single Republican senator save one voted yes, while every Democrat voted no.
I would bet dollars to doughnuts that the votes on future Supreme Court justices will resemble the close votes on Jackson and Barrett rather than the unanimous vote in favor of O’Connor.
* * * * *
I noted above that only one Republican senator failed to vote to confirm Amy Coney Barrett to the Supreme Court.
That one Republican senator was Susan Collins of Maine, who was also one of the only three Republicans who voted to confirm Ketanji Brown Jackson, a liberal justice appointed by Joe Biden.
Collins is up for re-election this year, and her opponents are hammering her because she voted to confirm Brett Kavanaugh when Trump nominated him to the Supreme Court in 2018. “A vote for Collins is a vote for Trump,” they say, “and a vote against reproductive rights.”
Susan Collins always has been pro-choice. (In 2022, she introduced a bill to codify Roe v. Wade after that decision was overturned by the Supreme Court.)
And she is arguably the most independent member of the U.S. Senate – she recently reaffirmed the independence she demonstrated by voting against Amy Coney Barrett and in favor of Ketanji Brown Jackson when she announced a few days ago that she would not vote to confirm Trump’s nominee for Attorney General.
But independence is no longer seen as a desirable quality for a politician. Neither is bipartisanship. (Collins has consistently been ranked as the most bipartisan member of the Senate. She voted with Presidents Obama and Biden as much as she voted with President Trump.)
![]() |
And heaven help candidates who are viewed as moderates. Extremism is clearly preferred in both parties these days. (The American Conservative Union gives Collins a 46% score when it comes to being conservative, while the American for Democratic Action – a liberal group – rates her as 45% liberal. That’s about as middle-of-the-road as it’s possible to be.)
Give her votes on the Barrett and Jackson nominations – not to mention her support of the two liberal Supreme Court justices nominated by President Obama – it’s ironic indeed that the consistently moderate and pro-choice Collins is being criticized for her Kavanaugh vote and painted as a Trump supporter. But most politicians wouldn’t recognize irony if it bit them in the behind.
Forget it, Jake – it’s politics.
* * * * *
Please don’t misunderstand my point today. I’m not saying you should vote for Susan Collins or against her – there are perfectly reasonable arguments on both sides of that debate, and it’s up to Maine voters to decide which are more compelling.
But as an aficionado of irony, I couldn’t resist pointing out such a juicy example of it. Although the more I think about it, the more I wonder if the appropriate term for what I wrote about above is hypocrisy rather than irony.
According to Psychology Today columnist Jeremy Sherman, “Hypocrisy means contradicting ourselves, being inconsistent, and talking out of both sides of our mouths. But that’s also what irony means. What then distinguishes hypocrisy from irony?”
That’s a good question. Hypocrisy and irony both involve a disparity between words and deeds. Some have distinguished the two by saying that while all hypocrisy has an ironic element, but not all irony involves hypocrisy.
I’ll stick with my choice of irony. But if you think hypocrisy is the more accurate term to use here, be my guest.
* * * * *
A final note: if you choose to comment on this post, PLEASE don’t accuse me of being MAGA or supporting baby-killing or other such BS.
That’s especially true if you’re someone I know. I get along just fine with my fellow basketball referees, and the people I meet at trivia, and the people I take bike trips with – until they start talking about politics. Occasionally someone has something thoughtful to say on that subject, but most of the people I hear talking about politics immediately prove themselves to be dumbasses.
I want to like everyone I meet – I really do. But it’s hard to like someone you don’t respect because they’re a dumbass.
* * * * *
Today’s featured recording hit #1 on the Billboard “Hot 100” in 1989, but the first time I heard it was at my local grocery store last week.
“Black Velvet” pays tribute to Elvis Presley. Fortunately, it sounds nothing like an Elvis record.
Click here to listen to “Black Velvet.”
Click here to buy that recording from Amazon.










