They say I got brains
But they ain’t doin’ me no good
I wish they could
No regular reader of 2 or 3 lines will be surprised to find Pet Sounds on my list of the greatest albums released during the first half of rock’s “Golden Decade.”
If you spend an evening sampling the vast body of writing about Pet Sounds, you’ll learn a lot of interesting things.
![]() |
For example, you’ll learn that Paul McCartney and John Lennon were great admirers of Pet Sounds, but Pete Townshend and Mick Jagger were not. (That makes sense when you compare Beach Boys records to the music put out by the Beatles, Who, and Stones.)
You’ll also learn that the Beach Boys’ record company was not enthusiastic about the album, which sold only moderately well in the U.S. and failed to garner even a single Grammy nomination. (The Beach Boys were not big stars in the UK prior to the release of Pet Sounds, but it did very well in the UK. The album reached #2 on the English album charts – the Sound of Music soundtrack kept Pet Sounds out of the top spot – and stayed in the top ten for six months.)
But you won’t learn why Pet Sounds is the greatest album in history by reading.
* * * * *
All the words in the world aren’t adequate to explain why Pet Sounds is so great. The only way to get its greatness is to listen to it. And not just once or twice.
I first listened to Pet Sounds in 1966, when I was a shy and angsty fourteen-year-old.
The last time I listened to it was more than fifty years later, when Brian Wilson performed the album in its entirety at the Kennedy Center in Washington, DC.
I have not listened to Pet Sounds since I attended that performance because I didn’t see how that experience could be topped.
* * * * *
Pet Sounds is first and foremost an album – not a collection of individual songs, which is what most albums are.
It’s often referred to as a concept album, but it’s not like Tommy, or The Wall, or other concept albums – it doesn’t tell a story, or have a specific theme.
Here’s what Brian Wilson had to say about Pet Sounds as a concept album:
If you take the Pet Sounds album as a collection of art pieces, each designed to stand alone, yet which belong together, you'll see what I was aiming at. . . . It wasn't really a song concept album, or lyrically a concept album; it was really a production concept album.
Wilson has put his finger on something essential here. A few years ago, I stopped writing about songs and started writing about records.
A great song doesn’t always make a great record. To make a great record, you need a great song – but you also need great production.
Pet Sounds has a number of exceptional songs. Wilson was a genius, but he was also an innocent – his compositions for Pet Sounds were complex and subtle, but appealed to the heart as much as to the head. (John Cale of the Velvet Underground said that Pet Sounds was “adult and childlike at the same time,” and he was right.)
But what sets Pet Sounds apart from all other albums is Wilson’s exceptional production. He threw in everything but the kitchen sink to give that record its unique sound – not only strings and horns, but also a theremin, a bicycle bell, a five-gallon water-dispensing jug, and barking dogs.
* * * * *
So . . . after telling you that words weren’t adequate to explain the greatness of Pet Sounds, what did I do? I wrote a lot of words attempting to explain the greatness of Pet Sounds.
Sorry about that, boys and girls – sometimes I just can’t help myself.
Click here to listen to Pet Sounds.
Click here to buy Pet Sounds from Amazon.





