I’ve been in this town so long
So long to the city
The day after Brian Wilson died, a group of Washington Post arts and entertainment writers put together a list of their 14 favorite Wilson songs.
That list includes “California Girls,” “Good Vibrations,” “God Only Knows,” and “Caroline, No” – which would probably be the four records I’d choose for the Beach Boys’ Mt. Rushmore if there were such a thing. (Kudos to the writer who picked “Caroline, No” – I think it’s very underappreciated.)
![]() |
Brian Wilson in 1961 |
But some of their other selections are real head-scratchers.
Take “Barbara Ann.” (Please!) “Barbara Ann” is a lot of fun to sing along with after a night of binge drinking. But if you play it when you’re sober, it loses its appeal after about 30 seconds. Also, it’s not a Brian Wilson composition . . . which should have disqualified it from consideration.
“Sloop John B” should have been given the title “Sloop John B-Side.” It has a certain loosey-goosey charm, but there’s really no there there. Once again, it’s not a Brian Wilson composition . . . so why would you include it on a list titled “14 essential Brian Wilson songs”?
Finally, there’s “This Whole World,” which was released on the Sunflower album in 1970. Like a lot of Wilson’s post-Pet Sounds songs, it’s distinctive and interesting. But in the final analysis, it doesn’t really work – the whole is less than the sum of its parts.
* * * * *
What Brian Wilson songs that weren’t included on the Post’s list are on my MUCH BETTER favorites list?
The most puzzling omission from the Post list is “I Get Around,” which is the quintessential Beach Boys pre-Pet Sounds single. And it sounds just as fresh today as it did in 1964.
“Let Him Run Wild” – which was the B-side of “California Girls” – was almost as perfectly conceived and executed as “I Get Around,” but the moods of the two records couldn’t be more different. While “I Get Around” is about cool guys doing cool guy stuff, “Let Him Run Wild” is about uncool guys with hopeless crushes on girls who are waaaaay out of their league. (Guess which of those groups I was a member of when I was in high school?)
I’d fill out the rest of my list with additional Pet Sounds selections. (The Post’s list includes four tracks from Pet Sounds, but that’s not nearly enough.)
* * * * *
I talk a lot about Pet Sounds – which is far and away the greatest pop music album ever.
![]() |
Brian Wilson in 1977 |
If I had to pick just one additional Pet Sounds track to add to the Post’s list, it would be “Here Today.”
But I don’t have to pick just one. So I’m also going to include “You Still Believe in Me,” “That’s Not Me,” “I’m Waiting for the Day,” and “I Know There’s an Answer.”
Don’t worry – I didn’t forget “I Just Wasn’t Made for These Times.” Like “In My Room” – which is included on the Post’s list – that song is a cri de coeur from deep within Brian Wilson’s troubled mind. But while the singer of “In My Room” will likely outgrow his teenage angst some day, the singer of “I Just Wasn’t Made for These Times” is a mature adult who has come to realize that his fear and anxiety will be with him for the rest of his life.
* * * * *
One final note.
I’m probably doing Wilson a disservice by not including any of his post-1966 songs on my favorites list.
![]() |
Brian Wilson in 2017 |
But I never bought any of the Beach Boys post-Pet Sounds records. And while I’m sure there are some good songs on those albums, I can’t imagine that any of them are good enough to displace any of the songs on my list.
Feel free to try to make me change my mind – as anyone who knows me will tell you, I have no problem admitting it when I’m wrong about something. (The last time that happened was in 1982.)
* * * * *
I decided to feature “Heroes and Villains” today even though it didn’t make my favorites list.
It’s a real tour de force record – in some ways, it beats “Good Vibrations” at its own game. But in the final analysis, there’s a little too much sound and fury in “Heroes and Villains.” And while that sound and fury doesn’t signify nothing, it doesn’t signify as much as “Good Vibrations.”
To put it another way, “Heroes and Villains” is analogous to witnessing a dog delivering a sermon – the fact that it’s a dog speaking is so remarkable that you tend to overlook the fact that the points he makes aren’t all that persuasive.
Click here to listen to the version of “Heroes and Villains” that was released in 1967 on the Smiley Smile LP. (There are a number of longer versions, one of which was released on the 2004 Brian Wilson Presents Smile album.)
Click here to buy “Heroes and Villains” from Amazon.